<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none;" alt="" src="https://px.ads.linkedin.com/collect/?pid=4361794&fmt=gif" />
Tabitha Whiting
Tabitha WhitingContent Marketing
The Volkswagen greenwashing scandal – and how to avoid it in your business carbon offsetting plans
The Volkswagen greenwashing scandal – and how to avoid it in your business carbon offsetting plans
Volkswagen is infamous in the climate world. But for all the wrong reasons. Their company offsetting was widely criticised as being nothing more than greenwashing – here's why.June 15, 2022
Volkswagen badge, shown on an old red car

Volkswagen is infamous in the climate world.

But for all the wrong reasons. Their company offsetting was widely criticised as being nothing more than greenwashing – even becoming a damning report by Greenpeace.

Why? What did they do wrong? Well, two main things:

  1. Offsetting without first reducing
  2. Funding low-quality projects.

Offsetting without first reducing

Volkswagen were criticised for not adequately addressing their own carbon emissions – which should always be the first step in a company’s sustainability strategy, before offsetting comes into the picture.

They had taken actions to reduce their own carbon footprint, especially improving the efficiency of their production. But, as the Greenpeace report points out, there was a long way for Volkswagen to go in terms of cutting their emissions – especially in terms of promoting the transition to electric cars and more sustainable car use.

VW's carbon footprint sham – the front cover of the Greenpeace report into Volkswagen's carbon offsetting

How could Volkswagen have avoided this accusation? By ensuring their plans to cut emissions were rigorous and included the entire value chain of their business. We'd always recommend aligning your plans to reduce company emissions with a rigorous, reputable framework – such as Science Based Targets – to ensure that your plans are going as far as possible, and properly align with wider net zero goals.

Science based targets – driving ambitious corporate climate action

Funding low-quality projects

Questions were also raised about the projects that Volkswagen chose to support through their offsetting programme. 

Specifically, there were doubts that the projects supported were permanent and additional – meaning that the actual impact of purchasing carbon offset credits in these projects is minimal. 

Purchasing offset credits from low-quality projects is a common trend to look out for when it comes to greenwashing in carbon offsetting. Typically, low-quality projects are selling carbon credits very cheap, which makes them seem like an easy, cost-effective option for businesses looking to neutralise their emissions. But the reality is that they rarely have the impact they claim to.

How could Volkswagen have avoided this accusation? Simply by making a deliberate policy to only support high-quality carbon offset projects like those in our library at Lune.

High-quality projects are:

  • Permanent: the carbon removal or emissions avoidance is long-term and will not be reversed e.g. in a reforestation if the forest is cut down in later years.

  • Additional: emissions reductions or carbon removal is generated in addition to what would have happened without the project existing.

  • Correctly estimated: projects can only claim reductions or removal of emissions where the impact has been accurately measured and quantified – and with a high-quality project you’d expect to see transparency about this process.

  • Single counted: a carbon registry provides assurance the carbon offset credit has not already been claimed by any other entity.

  • Typically more expensive: running a successful and impactful carbon offsetting project is hard and usually requires a lot of time and labour, so be wary of cheap offsets - they rarely have the impact they claim to have. 

Read more in our explainer: what are high-quality carbon offsets?


Avoiding accidental greenwashing – don’t be like Volkswagen 

If you’re exploring carbon offsetting as an action for your company – don’t worry.

It can seem scary, but whilst greenwashing is a valid concern it isn’t an inevitability. 

You just need to know how to approach offsetting without greenwashing – including the factors covered here: addressing your own carbon emissions and focusing on high-quality offsets. 

Because done right, offsetting is a way to make a real difference on climate change through business.

Popular articles

Lune x Visa
Lune partners with Visa to help accelerate meaningful climate action

Lune will offer trusted, high-quality carbon projects to Visa’s global network of merchants, banks, and partners – working together with a goal to scale climate action.

Photo of a direct air capture plant, with mountains and blue sky in the background
How to suck all that carbon we’ve emitted back out of the atmosphere – a deep dive on Direct Air Capture

We’ve emitted billions of tonnes of carbon emissions and now (alongside drastically reducing those emissions) we need to get it out of the atmosphere. How do we do that? Well, Direct Air Capture is one solution – here’s everything you need to know about it.

Company emissions, 2022 report
Climate disclosure regulations are coming into effect across the world – here’s what you need to know

Legislation requiring companies to report on sustainability – their environmental impact and the risks and opportunities facing the business – is upcoming across the globe, from the EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive to the US proposed SEC climate disclosure rule. 

Subscribe to our monthly newsletter – and get a free copy of our Complete Guide to Offsetting

Offsetting guide
Offsetting guide